Butt Plugs
Butt plugs in silicone, glass and metal, in small, medium and large sizes, including vibrating and jeweled styles.
Buying tip: Always choose a plug with a flared base. Start small and use plenty of water-based lube.
305 products · page 1 of 7
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug
$25.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
2 options
VeDO Bump Mini Rechargeable Anal Plug
$39.99VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
2 options
b-Vibe Weighted Snug Plug
$45.00VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
8 options
The Beat Magic Power Plug
$31.02VIP price
Save 36% with VIP
2 options
Sport Fucker Crossfit Plug
$31.95VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
2 options
b-Vibe Vibrating Snug Plug
$85.50VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
2 options
Creature Cocks - Creature Silicone Butt Plug
$25.14VIP price
Save 35% with VIP
2 options
Nu Sensuelle Mini Butt Plug
$51.99VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
2 options
Perfect Fit Tunnel Plug
$35.95VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
2 options
Nexus Ace Remote Control Butt Plug
$53.32VIP price
Save 39% with VIP
3 options
Nu Sensuelle Remote Control Rechargeable Mini Plug
$83.99VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
2 options
Evolved Luminous Anal Plug
$37.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Shots Ouch Beads Butt Plug with Cock Ring - Glow in the
$25.96VIP price
Save 35% with VIP
Nexus Bendz Plug
$52.15VIP price
Save 44% with VIP
3 options
Oxballs Morphhole 1 Gaper Plug Small - Black Ice
$46.93VIP price
Save 63% with VIP
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set
$67.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Shots Ouch Butt Plug with Cock Ring - Glow in the
$25.96VIP price
Save 35% with VIP
Oxballs Morphhole 2 Gaper Plug Large - Black Ice
$66.09VIP price
Save 64% with VIP
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set
$51.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Shots Ouch Butt Plug with Cock Ring & Ball Strap - Glow in the
$25.96VIP price
Save 35% with VIP
Fox Tail Small Plug
$26.02VIP price
Save 35% with VIP
5 options
Pretty Love Tarion Thrusting Butt Plug with Multi Color Bottom
$30.76VIP price
Save 36% with VIP
VeDO Trio Anal Plug Set
$35.99VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Evolved Joy Sticks 2 pc Plug Set - Black/Chrome
$77.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Shots Ouch Butt Plug Set - Glow in the
$37.58VIP price
Save 37% with VIP
Fox Tail Medium Plug
$28.34VIP price
Save 43% with VIP
6 options
Pretty Love Varian Large Butt Plug with Multi Color Bottom
$28.81VIP price
Save 36% with VIP
VeDO Plug Rechargeable Anal Plug
$45.99VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Evolved Twisted Love 3 pc Plug Set
$61.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Shots Ouch Puppy Tail Plug - Glow in the
$25.96VIP price
Save 35% with VIP
Fox Tail Large Plug
$32.99VIP price
Save 45% with VIP
7 options
Crystal Jellies 6" Double Pop Plug
$25.02VIP price
Save 43% with VIP
2 options
VeDO Twist Rechargeable Anal Plug
$45.99VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Evolved Advanced Vibrating Rechargeable Metal Plug
$71.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Evolved Mini Butt Plug
$41.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Rimming Plug
$89.99VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Evolved Beginner Vibrating Rechargeable Metal Plug
$65.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Glas 5" Fist Butt Plug
$31.83VIP price
Save 36% with VIP
Evolved Plug & Play Remote Anal Plug
$99.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Leopard Novice Plug
$89.99VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Enhancer Vibro Plug & Penis Sheath
$49.77VIP price
Save 38% with VIP
Glas 4" Butt Plug Cornstar
$26.02VIP price
Save 35% with VIP
Evolved Kong Rechargeable Anal Plug
$109.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
b-Vibe Butties Bulb Tapered Prostate Plug
$27.00VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Icicles No. 44 Hand Blown Glass Butt Plug
$30.00VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
2 options
Glas 7.25" Glass Beaded Butt Plug
$37.64VIP price
Save 37% with VIP
Evolved Hole Punch Anal Plug Set
$71.98VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
b-Vibe Butties Ringer Cock Ring & Prostate Plug
$27.00VIP price
Save 40% with VIP
Common questions
How much do butt plugs cost?
VIP member prices on this page run from $6.45 to $139.00. Every item also shows the regular price, so you can see what VIP saves.
Is shipping and billing discreet?
Yes. Orders ship in plain packaging and billing is discreet. Adults 18+ only.
What does VIP membership include?
VIP is $24.95 a month and gives member pricing on everything in the store. See the VIP page for the details.